The author says that, given the same prompt to generate a browser-based Minecraft-style sandbox game, the Hy4 version could not detect the mouse and had reversed directional controls. He considers this result clearly behind DeepSeek v4.1 Flash. The original post's video shows footage of both games, but it does not disclose a reproducible runtime environment or control-test record.
Suitable for assessing: The visible output of two games and the control issues reported by the author in one browser sandbox-game generation task.
Not suitable for extrapolating to: Other game or web development tasks, general coding ability, model reliability, or control behavior in different clients.
Model versions covered: DeepSeek v4.1 Flash; Tencent HY4 (labeled “hy4” in the video, with no specific version number, so it is unclear whether this was the GA version).
Test environment or client: The author says the same prompt was used and mentions web and other technologies; the client, agent, browser, tool permissions, and execution chain are unspecified.
Reasoning level and parameters: Not specified.
In a reply to the original post, the author provided the full prompt: it asks the model to implement as complete a Minecraft-style sandbox game as possible that runs in a browser, without simplifying it into a demo or MVP, and to output runnable code in one go. The author says each side took “about an hour,” but does not specify when timing started or ended, the number of runs, or whether any additional modifications were made. The original post includes an approximately 38-second video showing the DeepSeek v4.1 Flash and hy4 results in stacked views.
Author's report: The Hy4 page could not detect the mouse and had reversed directional controls; the author concludes that Hy4 falls clearly behind DeepSeek v4.1 Flash. The post provides no control-event details or retest record, so these issues are reported by the author and have not been independently reproduced.
What is visible in the video: The top view, labeled “DeepSeek v4.1 Flash,” shows snow, trees, a first-person hand holding a block, a crosshair, hotbar, status bar, and minimap. The bottom view, labeled “hy4,” shows grass, trees, flowers, a crosshair, hotbar, and minimap. The footage available during collection shows that both generated scenes with a first-person sandbox-game interface; the footage alone cannot establish whether interaction worked or how the overall quality compared.
Author's additional note on time: About one hour for each, with no precise figures or timing method provided.
| Item | DeepSeek | Hy4 |
|---|---|---|
| Label in post | DeepSeek v4.1 Flash | hy4 |
| Prompt | Same browser-based Minecraft-style sandbox-game prompt, according to the author | Same, according to the author |
| Time taken | About 1 hour, according to the author's reply | About 1 hour, according to the author's reply |
| Control issues reported by the author | No similar issue reported in the original post | Mouse not detected; directional controls reversed |
| Visible output | Upper half of video: snowy scene and first-person game interface | Lower half of video: grassy scene and first-person game interface |
This personal test supports the conclusion that, in one task using the same prompt, the author reported mouse and directional-control problems in the page generated by Hy4 and considered DeepSeek v4.1 Flash's result better. The prompt and video are visible, but the exact Hy4 version, runtime client, agent/harness, tools and browser settings, control-test procedure for either side, and scoring criteria were not disclosed. The approximately one-hour figure is also the author's estimate. This does not establish performance for the GA version or support generalizing a single result into a broad capability gap between the two models.
The full prompt is available in a reply to the original post, and the video shows scenes from both games. Reproducing the comparison would also require identifying the exact model versions, clients, and agents/harnesses on both sides; recording tool permissions, run counts, and timing rules; and checking the mouse, directional keys, and other interactions using the same steps. The current source does not provide this information.
Hy4