The post shows both a single-file 3D game prompt and Hydrogen's gameplay, making it an example of a complex creative coding task. The author presents a personal demo, which cannot establish the models' relative performance under controlled conditions.
Suitable task: Generate a third-person 3D exploration game prototype in a single HTML file, with a scene, interaction mechanics, explorable areas, and visual effects.
Unsuitable task: Assess overall coding ability across models or infer the quality of a complete game.
Applicable model version: The author identifies the model as Gemini 4 Hydrogen (Extra High).
Applicable client, agent, or API: Not specified.
Recommended reasoning level and parameters: Only the author's use of Extra High is documented; other parameters are not specified.
The original long prompt is not transcribed. Its task breakdown can be reused:
Specify the deliverable and perspective: a single HTML file and a third-person 3D game.
Describe the themed world, visual style, and overall exploration goal.
List the core interaction systems and their states or unlock rules.
Specify the opening sequence, explorable areas, and progression changes.
Add atmosphere goals such as environmental dynamics, NPCs, and sound effects.
State the expected scale and set quality requirements, such as rendering the full scene and avoiding simplified terrain.
The author says they gave Gemini 4 Hydrogen (Extra High) a prompt for a single-file HTML game based on Howl's Moving Castle, then displayed its result alongside one from Opus 5 Medium generated about four months earlier. The post's first image shows Hydrogen's gameplay and information indicating that a single-file HTML game was generated.
The post body includes the game's input description. The first image in the gallery places Opus 5 Medium and Gemini 4 Hydrogen side by side; the Hydrogen side is labeled Extra High, single-file HTML, and 0 errors.
The author's settings and timing differ: Hydrogen used Extra High, while Opus used Medium and was run about four months earlier. Comments also point out that the model tier and reasoning level should be held constant. The image is therefore a demo, not a controlled comparison.
The body contains two similar but not identical long prompt descriptions. “The same prompt” is the author's claim; the post alone cannot establish whether the two inputs were word-for-word identical.
The screenshots show that the post presents a generated result. They do not prove that every game feature works, that the source code was independently checked, or that the result matches the prompt's full scale and level of detail. The post does not specify the client, code execution environment, or reproducible steps.
Use the original post's task structure to write concise, clear requirements for a scene and gameplay, then run them in the target client. Record the exact model version, reasoning level, client, and generated file. Separately check that the page loads, the main interactions work, and the browser console has no errors. Do not generalize the post's model comparison to other tasks.
Gemini 4 Hydrogen